Périodique
Using self-generated identification codes to match questionnaires in panel studies of adolescent substance use
(Utilisation de codes d'identification personnalisés pour comparer les questionnaires au cours d'une étude de panel sur l'usage de substance chez des adolescents)
Auteur(s) :
GRUBE, J. W. ;
MORGAN, M. ;
KEARNEY K. A.
Année :
1989
Page(s) :
159-171
Langue(s) :
Anglais
ISBN :
0306-4603
Refs biblio. :
9
Domaine :
Drogues illicites / Illicit drugs
Discipline :
EPI (Epidémiologie / Epidemiology)
Thésaurus mots-clés
ALCOOL
;
TABAC
;
METHODE
;
ENQUETE
;
TEST
;
ANONYMAT
;
SECRET PROFESSIONNEL
;
ADOLESCENT
;
MILIEU ETUDIANT
Thésaurus géographique
IRLANDE
Note générale :
Addictive Behaviors, 1989, 14(2), 159-171
Résumé :
FRANÇAIS :
On utilise des codes basés sur des caractéristiques personnelles des sujets, qui permettent de coupler des questionnaires lors d'un nouveau test sans pouvoir identifier spécifiquement ceux qui ont répondu. Les questionnaires dont les sept éléments du code d'identification sont corrélés présentent un profil différent de ceux qui ne le sont pas. Pour pallier ce biais, on étudiera donc les questionnaires dont six éléments sur sept sont corrélés. Ceci est particulièrement important dans des enquêtes sur des sujets sensibles comme celle-ci où de jeunes étudiants irlandais sont interrogés sur leur consommation et leur intention de consommer de l'alcool, du tabac et d'autres produits toxiques.
ENGLISH:
The usefulness of self-generated codes for anonymously linking data in panel studies of adolescent substance use was investigated in a study of Irish post-primary students and sample bias resulting from this procedure considered. A seven element code exactly matched 71% of questionnaires over one month when school absences were taken into account. Allowing codes to differ on one element to compensate for respondent errors increased matching success to 88% without resulting in appreciable mismatching. Unmatched compared with exactly matched respondents tended to be male, lower SES, have more spending money, and were less closely bonded to school and religion. They also were more involved in smoking, drinking, and drug use and had more favorable beliefs toward these behaviors. Off-one respondents generally were intermediate on these measures. However, the differences were small and the characteristics of the combined matched respondents closely resembled those of the total sample. When predicting substance use, the regression coefficients were quite similar for the matched and unmatched groups and the total sample. The data thus provide evidence for the usefulness of self-generated codes in panel and longitudinal studies of adolescents when anonymity and confidentiality are of concern.
On utilise des codes basés sur des caractéristiques personnelles des sujets, qui permettent de coupler des questionnaires lors d'un nouveau test sans pouvoir identifier spécifiquement ceux qui ont répondu. Les questionnaires dont les sept éléments du code d'identification sont corrélés présentent un profil différent de ceux qui ne le sont pas. Pour pallier ce biais, on étudiera donc les questionnaires dont six éléments sur sept sont corrélés. Ceci est particulièrement important dans des enquêtes sur des sujets sensibles comme celle-ci où de jeunes étudiants irlandais sont interrogés sur leur consommation et leur intention de consommer de l'alcool, du tabac et d'autres produits toxiques.
ENGLISH:
The usefulness of self-generated codes for anonymously linking data in panel studies of adolescent substance use was investigated in a study of Irish post-primary students and sample bias resulting from this procedure considered. A seven element code exactly matched 71% of questionnaires over one month when school absences were taken into account. Allowing codes to differ on one element to compensate for respondent errors increased matching success to 88% without resulting in appreciable mismatching. Unmatched compared with exactly matched respondents tended to be male, lower SES, have more spending money, and were less closely bonded to school and religion. They also were more involved in smoking, drinking, and drug use and had more favorable beliefs toward these behaviors. Off-one respondents generally were intermediate on these measures. However, the differences were small and the characteristics of the combined matched respondents closely resembled those of the total sample. When predicting substance use, the regression coefficients were quite similar for the matched and unmatched groups and the total sample. The data thus provide evidence for the usefulness of self-generated codes in panel and longitudinal studies of adolescents when anonymity and confidentiality are of concern.
Affiliation :
Prevention Research Center, Berkeley, CA, USA
Cote :
Abonnement